Jenny Chan 陳詠欣
Sep 21, 2011

Vodafone aligns with Hutchison Telecom, SmarTone responds to criticism

HONG KONG - Vodafone has hooked up with Hutchison Telecom a day after calling it quits with SmarTone, which has outlined its position on the end of the alliance.

Hutchison comes between SmarTone and Vodafone
Hutchison comes between SmarTone and Vodafone

A strategic partnership was formed between Vodafone and Hutchison Telecom yesterday, which will start working together "upon the expiration of Vodafone's contractual agreement with its existing partner in Hong Kong".

That existing partner is SmarTone, which agreed not to renew its marketing cooperation with Vodafone on Monday.

In December, Hutchison Telecom Hong Kong will become the preferred non-equity partner of Vodafone in roaming and global corporate sales services. It will also be entitled to use the Vodafone brand, devices and services in Hong Kong.

Shirley Chung, general manager of customer relationship development of SmarTone-Vodafone elaborated on the reason for the fallout as divergence in strategies for marketing positioning, service and product propositions, quality, retail operations and best practice sharing.

"The business case for continuing the cooperation with Vodafone is no longer there, as costs outweigh benefits. SmarTone will be better off (alone) in terms of cost, operational focus, and flexibility," she said.

Chung continued that Vodafone has little brand impact in Hong Kong as people still generally refer to SmarTone's Chinese name locally. The local telco would not be running a brand campaign to disassociate itself from Vodafone due to its brand expression being based on off SmarTone's expression 'Love the difference', not Vodafone's 'Power to you'.
 
This follows news on the same day that Vodafone has been accepted as a member of the Conexus Mobile Alliance in Asia, which means a series of partnerships with Hutchison Telecom in Hong Kong, FarEasTone in Taiwan, NTT DOCOMO in Japan, SMART in the Philippines, StarHub in Singapore and TrueMove in Thailand.
 
Vodafone Global Enterprise’s sales director for Asia and sub-Saharan Africa Stevan Hoyle said this would also help Vodafone and Conexus members to net MNC customers seeking to ink a single telecommunications contract instead of multiple deals across various geographies.
 
In Hong Kong, the Vodafone-Hutchison duo plans to provide customers with "enhanced network coverage, harmonised roaming rates across multiple countries and greater cost efficiencies". 
 
In response, Chung held the view that synergies from these alliances are "few and far between, with no material cost or technology advantages. "There is actually no such thing as an 'international edge', we believes that all markets are local; there are vast differences in customer needs, culture, market dynamics, and there is no one-size-fits-all international strategy that works well," she said. 
 
HTHKH's chief executive officer Peter Wong however said the partnership will "enhance abilities to meet growing demand among multinational corporations for sophisticated voice and data communications services".
 
SmarTone-Vodafone has been late to the 4G LTE game, but Chung said that technology is "not mature now as it's still unstable and buggy", with no supporting LTE devices except one dongle that’s available in the market (by CSL). She said SmarTone will launch it when "the time is right".
 
Along with HTHKH's 'Three' brand and CSL, SmarTone-Vodafone claim the shouting rights of being official Apple distributors in Hong Kong. Chung assured that the distributorship for the imminent iPhone 5 launch will not be affected by its non-cooperation with Vodafone.
 
 
 

 

Source:
Campaign China

Related Articles

Just Published

1 day ago

Creative Minds: How Yuhang Lin went from dreaming ...

The Shanghai-based designer talks turning London Tube etiquette into a football game, finding inspiration in the marketing marvels of The Dark Knight, and why he wants to dine with Elon Musk.

1 day ago

Happy holidays from team Campaign!

As the Campaign Asia-Pacific editorial team takes a holiday bulletin break until January 6th, we bid farewell to 2024 with a poetic roundup of the year's defining marketing moments—from rebrands that rocked to cultural waves that soared.

2 days ago

Year in review: Biggest brand fails of 2024

From Apple’s cultural misstep to Bumble’s billboard backlash and Jaguar’s controversial rebrand, here’s Campaign’s take on the brands that tripped up in 2024, offering lessons in creativity, cultural awareness, and the ever-tricky art of reading the room.

2 days ago

Former GroupM China executives to face Shanghai ...

EXCLUSIVE: The trio will appear before Shanghai's Intermediate Court next week, marking the latest chapter in the bribery scandal that rocked WPP's GroupM China in October last year.