Sarah Shearman
Sep 30, 2015

Can ad blockers clean out brands' 'cheap sushi'?

NEW YORK — Ask advertisers for their views on ad blockers and, for a long time, the answer would most likely have been a "meh."

Advertising Week speakers say the problem isn't ad blockers but bad ads
Advertising Week speakers say the problem isn't ad blockers but bad ads

The issue, however, has dominated discussion at Advertising Week, as the rising popularity of the software serves as a reckoning for the industry: Maybe a lot of consumers don't want to be reached with marketing messages.

"There isn't a free pass for bad advertising," said Mark Thompson, president and chief executive of the New York Times Company, when asked about the issue during a panel discussion today. He said that journalism's values around producing quality content should apply to advertising too. "Crap targeting doesn't help," he added.

Netflix Chief Marketing Officer Kelly Bennett, who spoke on a panel yesterday, shared the same view. "I don't think consumers are frustrated with advertising, I think they are frustrated with badly targeted advertising," he said.

Advertisers must be aware of the "creep factor" of being followed around the web by an ad for a product they browsed weeks before. In some cases, consumers are served re-targeted ads for products they have already bought. A better understanding of the consumer will help resolve this issue, Bennett said.

Ad blocking is a "little bit overblown" at this stage, Rob Bear, creative director at Vox, said today during a panel about native advertising. If anything, ad blocking is a good thing because it filters out the audience that is unlikely to be responsive to advertising, he said. "That way you can focus on the audience that more likely to engage with talking to brands," he said.

Many speakers have heralded native advertising as the antidote to ad blocking. Pete Cashmore, founder and CEO of Mashable, said he thinks native video advertising could be the solution to the problem.

Ad blocking and native advertising actually share a lot in common, said Dan Greenberg, chief executive of Sharethrough. The stated values of software like AdBlock Plus reject irrelevant, noisy advertising: exactly the issue native advertising is trying to solve. "As long as publishers survive, they will survive in a world where native is the dominant ad format."

The rise of ad blocking could see publishers distribute content on social platforms — not only because blocking software doesn't work there, but they have the added benefit of targeting it to relevant audiences.

The general consensus so far is that bad advertising is contributing to the rise in ad blocking, and the onus is on the industry to produce better quality content. Jon Steinberg, chief executive of the Daily Mail North America, had some sage advice about the perils of bad advertising, likening it to sushi. "You never want to buy cheap sushi."

Source:
Campaign US

Related Articles

Just Published

2 days ago

Creative Minds: FCB's Claire Herselman transforms ...

Get to know the senior copywriter who moved to London at 18 and worked as a barista.

2 days ago

WPP boss Mark Read hits back at employee vitriol ...

CEO told Campaign's sister title, PRWeek, that some of the comments being made about his decision to require all employees to work in the office at least four days a week do not reflect the views of many staff.

2 days ago

How young Malay-Muslim women are spending and consuming

Malay-Muslim women are leading a consumer revolution, with 93% preferring local groceries and 89% choosing homegrown F&B, according to a new analysis. Brand boycotts are reshaping loyalty, while halal certification, affordability, and shared cultural identity are the decisive factors in their purchasing power.

2 days ago

Singtel's attempt to reimagine LNY traditions ...

The telco's annual festive film blends humour and lightheartedness, but its reliance on traditional gender roles dampens an otherwise innovative take on festive preparations.